For a long time I’ve been curious about a dinner party in
Paris on 18 May 1922. Now all has been revealed in Stephen Klaidman’s new
book*, a biography of the hosts that evening, Sydney and Violet Schiff.
The Schiffs were committed patrons of (and friends with)
artists, writers and musicians, and Sydney himself wrote autobiographical
novels under the pseudonym Stephen Hudson.
It was a late dinner in an upstairs room at the Hotel
Majestic, following the first night of Stravinsky’s new burlesque-ballet at the
Opéra, Le Renard,
which was given by Diaghilev’s Ballet Russes, the same group who had shocked
Paris with The Rite of Spring. Diaghilev and several of his dancers came to the
dinner, as did the designer of the new production, one Pablo Picasso.
But not content with having the leading composer, artist and
impresario of the day (and maybe of the century) at their dinner, the Schiffs
had also invited two writers, arguably the greatest literary innovators of the
twentieth century: Marcel Proust and James Joyce.
Proust arrived around midnight and proceeded to make
conversation with Stravinsky, saying how much he loved the late quartets of
Beethoven and comparing Stravinsky with Beethoven. Sensing that this was Proust
trying to show off his connoisseurship in music, Stravinsky took offence: “I
detest Beethoven,” he announced.
Joyce arrived around 2:30am, shabby and drunk. Proust had
not read any of Joyce’s work ‒
Ulysses was causing a great stir at the time, but not with Proust. And Joyce
had read just a few pages of Proust’s magnum opus, In Search of Lost Time, and
disclosed to a friend some time later that “I cannot see any special talent but
I am a bad critic.” They found little to say to each other, these two titans of
literature.
At the end of the “evening” they shared a taxi together with
the Schiffs. Joyce lit a cigarette, but was silent. Proust talked incessantly –
but not to Joyce.
And so finished the starriest dinner party of all time.
*Stephen Klaidman, Sydney and Violet: Their Life with TS
Eliot, Proust, Joyce and the Excruciatingly Irascible Wyndham Lewis, Nan A
Talese / Doubleday